The Nifty is up 10.1% in November and the Sensex closed at a nine-month high of 82,532. If your mutual fund has not kept up, S&P's SPIVA India scorecard for mid-year 2026 has a category-by-category answer.
Should you pick an index fund or an active fund? It depends on the category. Over five years to June 2026, 85% of active large-cap funds trailed their benchmark after fees — index funds lead there. In mid and small caps the contest is closer: only 15% trailed over one year, but 55% over five. Costs decide the gap.
What SPIVA 2026 actually measured
SPIVA — S&P Indices Versus Active — is S&P Dow Jones Indices' twice-yearly scorecard. It counts how many actively managed funds trailed their benchmark, net of fees, over 1, 3, 5 and 10 years; the mid-year 2026 edition uses data to 30 June 2026.
Two features make it the most honest scoreboard in Indian funds: it counts funds that were merged or closed, so dead funds cannot be quietly dropped — roughly a quarter disappeared in ten years — and it measures what investors actually received, after fees.
One caveat: SPIVA measures large-cap funds against the S&P India LargeMidCap index, not the Nifty 50 — some analysts call that a tougher bar. The percentages below are the scorecard's own figures.
Large-cap: where active funds lose most
In large caps the verdict is the least ambiguous in Indian fund data: over five years to June 2026, 84.9% of active large-cap funds trailed their benchmark — 17 in every 20. Over ten years, 74% trailed; over one year, 79%.
Why do so many lose where research is deepest? Hundreds of analysts cover the same 100 large-cap companies, prices adjust fast, and a manager's edge must survive a fee of roughly 0.80–1.20% a year on a direct plan — the manager must beat the index by more than the fee, every year, for years.
ELSS tax-saving funds tell the same story: 71% trailed over five years, 80% over ten. If your tax-saving money sits in an active ELSS fund, the odds are not on its side.
Mid and small-cap: where active funds fought back
Mid and small caps are where the scorecard gets interesting — and where "index always wins" is wrong. Over the year to June 2026, only 15% of active mid and small-cap funds trailed their benchmark. In calendar 2025, only about 12% trailed. For a full year, most active managers in this corner genuinely beat the index.
But the longer record pulls the other way: 55% trailed over five years, 82% over ten. The short-term edge is real and fragile — a manager who wins in a rising small-cap market can lose it when the cycle turns.
The honest reading is category-dependent. Large-cap active management has a long, consistent record of trailing; mid and small-cap active management has a real but unreliable edge — good years happen, and they do not reliably repeat.
The ₹11.2 lakh cost of a 1% fee
Fees are where the argument stops being abstract. Take Priya, 30, who invests ₹10,000 a month by SIP for 20 years — ₹24 lakh in total. Assume, for illustration only, a 12% gross market return in both cases. The only difference is the fee.
Index fund at 0.10% expense ratio, keeping 11.9% a year: corpus ₹98,57,098.
Active fund at 1.00% on a direct plan, keeping 11.0% a year: corpus ₹87,35,731.
The gap: ₹11,21,367 — about 13% more in the index pocket, for the identical gross return.
At 1.50% the corpus falls to ₹81,75,968 and the gap widens to ₹16,81,130. At ten years the gap is only ₹1,19,733 — the damage compounds slowly, then all at once. The ₹98.6 lakh headline needs its inflation figure beside it: at 6% inflation it is worth about ₹30.7 lakh in today's rupees.
Loading the calculator…
Estimates from your inputs and the assumptions shown; returns are not guaranteed. Education only, not investment advice. Open the full SIP Calculator.
The myfw app · free to use
Keep these numbers.
The free myfw app saves your SIP Calculator scenarios, works offline and reminds you to stay on track.
On your phone? Open this page there to jump straight into the app.
A framework for choosing by category
No ranking of funds follows — a framework for thinking, scored 18 November 2026, weights stated so you can disagree.
5-year SPIVA record, large-cap (weight 30%): index 5/5, active 1/5 — 85% of active funds trail.
5-year SPIVA record, mid and small-cap (weight 20%): index 3/5, active 3/5 — 55% trail, a genuine contest.
Cost drag over 20 years (weight 25%): index 5/5, active 2/5 — the ₹11.2 lakh gap above.
Downside defence (weight 15%): index 3/5, active 3/5 — no verified edge either way in 2026.
Simplicity, no manager risk (weight 10%): index 5/5, active 3/5 — an index fund needs only a tracking-error check.
Weighted total: index funds 4.30 out of 5, active funds 2.15 out of 5. The framework's output, not advice: for a large-cap core the evidence for index funds is strong; for a mid and small-cap satellite, active funds have a real case — but only with a 5–10 year horizon and a hard look at the fee.
Before you change anything
Three checks come before any switch. First, switching triggers tax: equity-fund gains above ₹1.25 lakh a year are taxed at 12.5% as long-term gains, and gains on units held under a year at 20%. Second, check your scheme's exit load, typically up to 1% in the first year. Third, check the tracking error of any index fund you consider — a cheap fund that tracks badly is no bargain.
One approach investors take is to direct new money first and leave existing holdings alone until the tax and exit-load maths is checked. The November rally is the worst moment to judge a fund: when the Nifty rises 10% in a month, almost every fund looks good. One good month tells you nothing — that is what the SPIVA numbers are for.
What is the SPIVA scorecard, and why should I trust it?
Does "85% of large-cap funds underperform" mean index funds always win?
How much does a 1% higher expense ratio actually cost over 20 years?
Should I switch all my active funds to index funds now?
Ready to start?
Check your largest fund's expense ratio and its category's SPIVA record today. Try your own numbers in the embedded SIP calculator on myfinancewisdom.com. Follow @myfwindia on Instagram for the daily checklist version of this guide. Get the myfw app on Google Play — 22+ calculators in your pocket.
Educational content only — not financial advice. Consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser for personal guidance; investments are subject to market risk.
Sources: S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA India Scorecard Mid-Year 2026 (data to 30 June 2026), as tabulated by Fundsage AI and Monzy, accessed 18 Nov 2026; The Economic Times, 18 Nov 2026 (Sensex/Nifty 9-month highs); The Hindu BusinessLine, morning report, 18 Nov 2026 (FPI November inflows $10.07bn, a monthly record); SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 2026, effective 1 Apr 2026; AMFI TER/BER disclosures.
myFinance Wisdom is an independent financial education platform, not a SEBI-registered Investment Adviser or Research Analyst. Information is for educational purposes only. Read the full disclaimer.
This guide does not yet link the official sources it relies on. Check rates, limits and rules with the regulator, the Income Tax Department or the provider before you act. How we source guides.
About the Author
myfw Editorial Team
Our independent editorial team explains personal finance for readers in India. Read our editorial policy to understand how we research, review, and correct our content.