The one ratio that settles most arguments
Divide the flat's price by its annual rent: ₹50,00,000 ÷ (₹15,000 × 12) = 27.8. That is the price-to-rent ratio. The rule of thumb used across Indian rent-vs-buy guides is simple: above 20, renting usually wins; below 15, buying starts to make sense; between 15 and 20, it is a judgement call on how long you will stay. At 27.8, this flat sits firmly in rent territory. The same story shows up as rental yield: ₹1,80,000 a year on a ₹50 lakh flat is 3.6%. Metro yields in India generally run 2.5–3.5%, so this flat is already at the generous end — and it still does not make buying pay. Guides put the break-even stay at 10–12 years in Bengaluru and Delhi NCR, and 13–15 years in Mumbai. Shorter than that, and the buying costs below eat the case for owning.What buying really costs
A home loan does not start at the EMI. RBI caps the loan-to-value ratio at 75–90% depending on loan size, so a 10–25% down payment is mandatory. On ₹50 lakh, that is ₹10 lakh upfront — before a single rupee of loan. The loan itself: ₹40 lakh at 8.5% over 20 years means an EMI of ₹34,713. Over 20 years you pay ₹83,31,103 in total — interest of ₹43,31,103, nearly as much as the loan itself. Then the costs nobody budgets for: stamp duty plus registration typically adds 6–8% of the property value, or ₹3–4 lakh here. In Mumbai that is 6% stamp duty including the metro cess plus 1% registration capped at ₹30,000; in Karnataka it is about 5.6% stamp duty plus 2% registration. Maintenance, society charges, home insurance and repairs sit on top, every year. Rates have moved this year. The RBI raised the repo rate to 5.50% on 7 October 2026, its first hike in nearly four years. Festive home-loan offers now start at 7.25% (Bank of Maharashtra, per BankBazaar data compiled 23 October 2026), with HDFC advertising from 7.45% for top-tier applicants. At that best-case 7.45%, the EMI on this loan is ₹32,102 — still 64% of a ₹50,000 take-home. The rate is not the problem. The salary is.Loading the calculator…
Estimates from your inputs and the assumptions shown; returns are not guaranteed. Education only, not investment advice. Open the full EMI Calculator.
The myfw app · free to use
Keep these numbers.
The free myfw app saves your EMI Calculator scenarios, works offline and reminds you to stay on track.
On your phone? Open this page there to jump straight into the app.
The rent-and-invest side
Renting leaves ₹19,713 a month that buying would have swallowed (₹34,713 EMI minus ₹15,000 rent). Invest that difference every month as a SIP at an assumed 12% a year for 20 years, and it grows to about ₹1.97 crore. Invest the ₹10 lakh deposit at the same assumed 12% for 20 years, and it becomes about ₹96.5 lakh. The renter's corpus: roughly ₹2.93 crore. The buyer, meanwhile, owns a flat. At an assumed 5% annual price growth, that ₹50 lakh flat is worth about ₹1.33 crore after 20 years. On these assumptions, the renter ends up ahead by more than ₹1.5 crore — but only if the ₹19,713 difference is actually invested every single month. That is the discipline test most renters fail: the money saved on rent quietly becomes spending, not investing. Renting wins on paper only when the gap is invested.Loading the calculator…
Estimates from your inputs and the assumptions shown; returns are not guaranteed. Education only, not investment advice. Open the full SIP Calculator.
The myfw app · free to use
Keep these numbers.
The free myfw app saves your SIP Calculator scenarios, works offline and reminds you to stay on track.
On your phone? Open this page there to jump straight into the app.
The sensitivity that flips the answer
Change one assumption and the winner changes. If the flat's price grows at 10% a year instead of 5%, it is worth about ₹3.36 crore after 20 years — and buying wins comfortably. Rent is not frozen either: at a 5% annual hike, ₹15,000 a month becomes roughly ₹23,300 by year 10 and roughly ₹37,900 by year 20. So the honest answer is conditional, not absolute. The 12% return and the 5% or 10% price growth are assumptions, not forecasts. Before deciding, check your city's actual price trend over the last 10 years and ask whether the flat you want is in a neighbourhood where prices genuinely compound — or one where they have been flat for a decade.Can a ₹50,000 salary actually carry this EMI?
The affordability rule is that all EMIs together should stay within 35–40% of take-home pay. A ₹34,713 EMI on a ₹50,000 take-home is 69.4% — it fails the rule by a wide margin, leaving too little for food, transport, savings and everything else. Rent at ₹15,000 is 30% of take-home, which passes comfortably. One small tailwind for renters: HRA exemption is now 50% of salary in eight cities, including Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Pune and Ahmedabad. It lowers the tax cost of renting for salaried employees, but it does not close a ₹19,713 monthly gap — it tips borderline cases, not this one. If the EMI is above 40% of your pay, the right move is to rent for now and revisit buying when your pay rises or the flat gets cheaper.Rent vs buy scorecard — 10 November 2026
Score the two options on five factors, weighted by what matters most to a first-home buyer: monthly cash flow (30%), 20-year wealth (25%), flexibility and job mobility (20%), stability and security (15%), tax and HRA (10%). Rent wins cash flow and flexibility by a wide margin. Buying wins stability. Wealth depends entirely on the price-growth assumption. There is no universal winner — only a conditional one: under about 10 years in one place, rent; over about 12 years in a city where prices actually grow, buying starts to win.Ready to start?
Run your own numbers today: compare the EMI on the flat you are eyeing with 35% of your take-home pay. Try your own numbers in the embedded EMI calculator on myfinancewisdom.com. Follow @myfwindia on Instagram for the daily checklist version of this guide. Get the myfw app on Google Play — 22+ calculators in your pocket.
Learn More